- Overview
- Property Details
- Video / 3D Tour
- Location
Experience the charm and legacy of 5D Stone Barn Way, Nantucket, a remarkable residence located within the iconic Stone Barn—originally constructed in the 1800s by master builder Charles Robinson as a grand stable for R. Gardner Chase. Now reimagined as private residences, this architectural treasure blends preserved historic craftsmanship with modern-day comfort. Step inside to soaring ceilings, original woodworking, and a dramatic central stairwell that leads to the tower—a unique feature offering panoramic views of Nantucket Harbor and the island beyond. The residence at 5D Stone Barn Way is steeped in history yet designed for today’s lifestyle, making it both a refined retreat and a rare piece of Nantucket heritage. Enjoy outdoor living in the private patio garden, perfect for alfresco dining or relaxing after a day at nearby Jetties Beach or strolling through the cobblestone streets of Town. With its unparalleled location, historical significance, and timeless elegance, 5D Stone Barn Way presents a truly special ownership opportunity. Offered mostly furnished and with no leases in place, this home will be ready for its next chapter beginning July 31st.
First Floor
Passing through the foyer and by the intricately carved staircase, the den is to one's left. Beyond is a power room and further, the great room. Anchored by a cobblestone propane fireplace and flanked with built-ins on either side, the space is home to the living area, and dining area. Glass doors lead out to the furnished patio, with an outdoor shower, and a garden oasis. Conveniently sited off the dining area, the kitchen has new countertops and matching quartz backslabs, top of the line appliances and a feature wall revealing some of the original cobblestone from the Barn's facade. Notable throughout are the 10'+ ceilings, extensive millwork and carvings.
Second Floor
The staircase is open in the center affording a view up and down all three levels. The primary suite showcases a king-sized bed, a private bathroom with a glass and tile shower and two-sink vanity, and a private balcony overlooking the Bird Sanctuary, a terrific vantage point to enjoy the 4th of July fireworks from the comfort of home. Back within the suite, there are two window seats with storage below, built-in cabinetry for storage and a closet with custom hanging space and drawers. The foyer leads to a full bathroom with a tile and glass tub/shower and beyond, the guest room. The guest room has two full-sized beds and a closet with the washer/dryer. A spiral staircase leading up to a delightful playroom completes the space.
Third Floor
The highlight of the Barn, this unit includes the beloved tower, which is currently set up as a home office. Lightfilled with windows, it's the ideal spot to catch the boats coming and going and have a special vantage view of Brant Point.
Basement
Crawl space running under the Barn accessed through an exterior bulkhead, home to the mechanicals and not to be used for storage. There are two sump pumps under the Barn; One is under Units A/B and the other is under Unit C, in addition to several dehumidifiers.
- Selling Date 7/29/2025
- Listed Date 5/22/2025
- Days on Market 68
- % To Listing Price 95
- Total Rooms 7
- Total Beds 2
- Full Baths 2
- Half Baths 1
- Year Built 1889
- Year Renovated 2022
- Zoning R5
- Views D/Hbr, Res
5D Stone Barn Way - Sales History
- Selling date: 7/29/2025Selling price: $3,750,000
- Selling date: 8/22/2013Selling price: $1,750,000
- Selling date: 10/4/2007Selling price: $2,310,000
- Selling date: 2/17/2006Selling price: $1,500,000
Location
What we like about Brant Point
Brant Point is a classic summer enclave, adjacent to Town, featuring a shoreline that runs from the White Elephant to Jetties Beach. The homes in this area vary from casual summer cottages to grand stately waterfront homes. Jetties Beach is well suited for calm water swimming with the convenience of public restrooms and changing rooms, a restaurant (The Sandbar at Jetties Beach), and Nantucket Community Sailing (NCS). Whether you want to relax on the beach, enjoy the outdoor dining, or rent a kayak or boat from NCS, Jetties Beach is an ideal family-friendly summer setting.
Learn moreRepresentation by Laura Belair
laura@greatpointproperties.com 508.221.4455Originally from Pennsylvania, Laura grew up in Vermont and was first introduced to the island during her college summers where she worked in many hospitality and retail-related establishments. Some of her favorite island activities include yoga, exploring conservation trails, and traveling with her husband Rich.
About
Questions? Let us reach out to you.
Message (Optional)
Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266
A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.